A North Fork
Classic Residence
A charming Southold single family residence set on 0.51 private acres. Three bedrooms, two full baths, and 1,588 square feet of comfortable living — moments from the vineyards, farms, and beaches of Long Island's celebrated North Fork.
870 Crittens Lane · Offered at $879,999 · $554/sqft
A Coastal Sanctuary on Long Island's North Fork
Tucked away on a quiet lane in the heart of Southold, this charming single family residence offers a rare blend of coastal character and timeless comfort. Set on just over half an acre, the home invites you into a peaceful North Fork retreat filled with natural light and enduring craftsmanship.
Originally built in 1954, this three-bedroom, two-bath residence spans 1,588 square feet of thoughtfully arranged living space. Get pre-qualified today and discover life among Southold's celebrated beaches, vineyards, and farm stands — North Fork living at its most inspired. Est. payment: $6,034/mo. Show legal disclaimer.
Property Details
870 Crittens Lane, Southold, NY
Offered at $879,999 — a charming single family residence on Long Island's coveted North Fork. Est. payment: $6,034/mo. Get pre-qualified today.
3 Bedrooms
Three well-appointed bedrooms offering comfortable retreats for family and guests, thoughtfully designed with abundant natural light.
2 Bathrooms
Two full bathrooms providing everyday comfort and convenience for residents and visitors alike.
1,588 Sqft
A well-proportioned 1,588 square feet of thoughtfully arranged living space at just $554/sqft—an outstanding value on the North Fork.
Single Family Residence
A classic residential single family home offering privacy, character, and the freedom to make it uniquely yours.
Built in 1954
Built in 1954, this home carries timeless mid-century character with enduring craftsmanship and lasting appeal.
0.51 Acre Lot
A generous 0.51-acre lot with no HOA fees—plenty of room to garden, entertain, and enjoy the outdoors in Southold, NY 11971.
870 Crittens Lane
Southold, NY 11971
Offered at $879,999 — a charming Southold single family residence featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and 1,588 sq ft of comfortable living space on a generous 0.51-acre lot. Built in 1954, this North Fork home blends classic character with everyday livability.
Classic North Fork Single Family Home
1,588 Sq Ft of Comfortable Living
0.51-Acre Southold Lot
Classic Cottage Kitchen
Restful Master Bedroom
Inviting Dining Room
Private Outdoor Retreat
$879,999
870 Crittens Lane, Southold, NY 11971
Est. payment: $6,034/mo — Show legal disclaimer
Get Pre-QualifiedSingle Family Residence
Residential property offering classic charm and enduring appeal on the North Fork of Long Island.
Built in 1954
A timeless mid-century home with decades of character, ready for its next chapter.
0.51 Acres Lot
Generous half-acre parcel providing space, privacy, and endless outdoor possibilities.
$554/sqft • $— Zestimate® • $— HOA
Competitive per-square-foot value with no HOA fees. Zestimate® currently unavailable.
870 Crittens Lane
Southold, NY 11971
3 Beds • 2 Baths • 1,588 sqft
Built 1954 • 0.51 Acres
1,588
Square Feet
0.51
Acre Lot
3/2
Beds / Baths
1954
Year Built
Schedule a
Private Viewing
Offered at $879,999 — discover 870 Crittens Lane in Southold, NY 11971. A charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath single family residence spanning 1,588 sqft on a 0.51-acre lot. Contact our listing team to arrange a confidential tour.
Property Address
870 Crittens Lane, Southold, NY 11971
List Price
$879,999 • $554/sqft
Est. payment: $6,034/mo • Get pre-qualified
Interior
3 Beds • 2 Baths • 1,588 sqft
Property Details
Single Family Residence, Residential
Built in 1954 • 0.51 Acres Lot
Valuation & Fees
Zestimate®: $--
HOA: $--
Disclaimer
Estimated monthly payment shown for informational purposes only. Show legal disclaimer for full details. Actual costs may vary based on financing terms, taxes, and insurance.
Request Information
Fill out the form below and we'll be in touch shortly.
Voices from Southold
Hear from the discerning buyers and North Fork enthusiasts who have discovered the timeless charm of 870 Crittens Lane, Southold, NY 11971—a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom single family residence offered at $879,999.
"870 Crittens Lane is a rare North Fork gem—private, beautifully maintained, and just moments from Peconic Bay. Set on a 0.51-acre lot with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and 1,588 sq ft of living space, this 1954-built residence exceeded every expectation at $879,999."
Alexander Whitfield
Private Buyer, Manhattan NY
"Southold offers an unmatched blend of vineyards, beaches, and tranquility. At $554/sqft, this Crittens Lane single family residence—with its 1,588 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space and estimated payment of $6,034/mo—captures the very best of the North Fork lifestyle."
Isabella Marchetti
North Fork Homeowner, Cutchogue NY
"From the mature landscaping across the 0.51-acre lot to the sun-drenched interiors of this 1954 classic, 870 Crittens Lane feels like a retreat. With no HOA and minutes from Founders Landing Beach and Southold Village, it is a true legacy home in the heart of the North Fork."
Jonathan & Elena Ashford
Homeowners, Southold NY 11971
Where the vineyards meet the sea
A storied hamlet on Long Island's North Fork — where centuries of maritime heritage give way to rolling farmland, celebrated wineries, and a school district that raises generations.
About Southold
Founded in 1640, Southold is one of the oldest English settlements in New York — a hamlet where farm stands, tasting rooms, and quiet bay beaches define the rhythm of daily life along the Peconic.
Vineyards & Tasting Rooms
Home to celebrated wineries — Bedell, Croteaux, Old Field — where maritime terroir yields distinctive rosés and coastal reds.
Beaches & Bayfront
Founders Landing, Horton Point Lighthouse, and miles of Peconic Bay shoreline — swimming, sailing, and sunsets over the water.
Farms & Fields
Roadside farm stands, pick-your-own orchards, and heritage stone-fruit growers preserve the North Fork's agrarian soul.
Village Life
Main Road boutiques, seafood shacks, historic churches, and neighborly cafés — the quiet luxury of small-town living.
Southold Schools
The Southold Union Free School District serves the hamlet with a tightly-knit, community-focused education — small class sizes and generations of local families.
Southold Elementary School
A nurturing foundation where curious young minds are met with attentive teachers, hands-on learning, and enrichment programs woven into the fabric of village life.
Southold Junior-Senior High School
Rigorous academics meet a genuine sense of belonging. Advanced coursework, championship athletics, and college-preparatory programs distinguish this beloved local institution.
Small
Class Sizes
Strong
Academics
Rooted
Community